COVID-19 physician/team treatment results

0.1% mortality with early treatment vs. 6.2% with late treatment (49× lower)

Early treatment0.1%average mortality2.2% hospitalized
Late treatment6.2%average mortality39% hospitalized
PhysicianCountryPatientsHospitalizedDied
Early treatmenttreatment on presentation
0/360 deaths for treatment within 3 days
Dr. Mohammed Tarek AlamBangladesh10000%
patients up to 84 years old
up to 88yo, 81% comorbidities
Dr. Flavio CadegianiBrazil3,45040.1%00%
Dr. Shankara ChettySouth Africa8,00000%
Dr. Ryan ColeUSA40000%00%
Dr. Marco CosentinoItaly392256.4%10.3%
earlier treatment results were better
Dr. Jeff DavisUSA6,00000%
Dr. DhanajayIndia50000%
Dr. Raphael FurtadoBrazil17010.6%00%
Rabbi Yehoshua GerziIsrael86010.1%00%
Dr. Ellen GuimarãesBrazil50081.6%20.4%
Dr. Syed HaiderUSA4,00050.1%00%
Dr. Sabine HazanUSA1,00000%
Dr. Mollie JamesUSA3,500401.1%10.0%
Dr. Roberta LacerdaBrazil55081.5%20.4%
Dr. Katarina LindleyUSA10055.0%00%
Dr. Ben MarbleUSA150,00040.0%
Dr. Edimilson MigowskiBrazil2,00070.3%20.1%
Dr. Abdulrahman MohanaSaudi Arabia2,73300%
Dr. Carlos NigroBrazil5,000450.9%230.5%
Dr. Benoit OchsLuxembourg80000%
Dr. OrtoreItaly24031.2%00%
Dr. Valerio PascuaHonduras415266.3%10.2%
one patient already on oxygen died
Dr. Sebastian PopRomania30000%
Dr. Brian ProctorUSA869202.3%20.2%
Dr. Didier RaoultFrance8,3152142.6%50.1%
Dr. Karin RiedTurkey23710.4%
up to 99yo, 73% comorbidities
patients up to 86 years old
Dr. Vipul ShahIndia8,00050.1%
Dr. Silvestre SobrinhoBrazil116108.6%00%
Dr. UnknownBrazil957161.7%20.2%
Dr. Vladimir ZelenkoUSA2,200120.5%20.1%
Early treatment236,1812.2%0.1%
Late treatmentno treatment until hospitalization
Dr. Jake Scott (**)USA1,00010010%
Dr. David Uip (*)Brazil2,20085039%542.5%
Late treatment3,20039%6.2%

Early-treatment physicians treated patients on presentation, while late-treatment physicians followed official guidance with treatment only on hospitalization. Groups are not randomized. Results are subject to selection and ascertainment bias and accurate analysis requires details of the patient populations and followup, however the results are consistent across many teams, and consistent with the extensive controlled clinical evidence showing a significant reduction in risk with many early treatments, and complementary/synergistic benefits with combined treatment.

Physicians using early combined treatment protocols had much lower hospitalization and mortality rates compared with those following guidelines focusing on late treatment. Results are subject to selection and ascertainment bias and accurate analysis requires details of the patient populations and followup, however the results are consistent across many teams, and consistent with the extensive controlled clinical evidence showing a significant reduction in risk with many early treatments, and complementary/synergistic benefits with combined treatments. (*) Dr. Uip reportedly prescribed early treatment for himself, but not for patients1. (**) Dr. Scott reports treating hundreds of patients and losing over a hundred, but has not provided specific numbers2. Dr. Scott reports following (and helping create) US guidelines.
References